How Amaranth lost over $2 billion on natural gas
How the hedge fund Amaranth Advisors came to hold most of one natural gas contract, why its margin requirements kept rising and what the regulators did afterwards. A narrated explainer.

Data to September 2014 · updated 2026-11-02
Key numbers
- $8 billion
i
What: Managed by the hedge fund Amaranth Advisors, 2006
How: The size of the whole fund, all strategies, not only energy. The whole portfolio had to be sold off after the natural gas losses.
Source: U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations · data to 2006.
managed by the hedge fund Amaranth Advisors, 2006
- over $2 billion
i
What: Lost on natural gas from the last week of August to mid-September 2006
How: Losses on the fund's natural gas positions only, not the whole fund. On 29 Aug 2006 alone, the natural gas holdings lost nearly $600 million.
Source: U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations · data to 2006.
lost on natural gas from the last week of August to mid-September 2006
- nearly 70 %
i
What: Of open positions in NYMEX natural gas futures for November 2006, held by Amaranth at the end of February 2006
How: Amaranth's share of the open interest in one contract: NYMEX natural gas futures for delivery in November 2006. In May it was between 60 and 70 %, at times as much as 75 %. Swaps on ICE are not included.
Source: U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations · data to 2006.
of open positions in NYMEX natural gas futures for November 2006, held by Amaranth at the end of February 2006
- 100,000
i
What: Natural gas contracts held by Amaranth in a single month, at most
How: NYMEX reviews a trader's position once it passes 12,000 natural gas contracts in any one month. That level triggers a review; it is not a limit.
Source: U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations · data to 2006.
natural gas contracts held by Amaranth in a single month, at most
- over $3 billion
i
What: In margin requirements by 8 Sep 2006
How: Margin is the money a trader must keep with the exchanges against possible losses. Amaranth's margin requirements rose by $944 million on 30 Aug 2006 and passed $2.5 billion on 31 Aug 2006.
Source: U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations · data to 8 Sep 2006.
in margin requirements by 8 Sep 2006
- $750,000
i
What: Civil penalty in Brian Hunter's 2014 settlement with the CFTC, with permanent bans on some kinds of trading
How: The CFTC filed a civil action against Amaranth and Brian Hunter in 2007, alleging attempted manipulation of natural gas futures prices on 24 Feb 2006 and 26 Apr 2006. Amaranth settled in 2009 and paid a $7.5 million civil penalty.
Source: U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission · data to 15 Sep 2014.
civil penalty in Brian Hunter's 2014 settlement with the CFTC, with permanent bans on some kinds of trading
What the numbers mean
Open interest is the number of futures contracts that are still open at the end of a trading day. Amaranth's share counts its contracts against all open contracts for the same delivery month on NYMEX; its swaps on ICE, another exchange, are not included. The share was largest in the contract for delivery in November 2006: nearly 70 % at the end of February 2006, between 60 and 70 % in May and as much as 75 % at times. Across all winter months, October 2006 to March of the next year, it reached 40 % at times.
NYMEX reviews a trader's position once it passes 12,000 natural gas contracts in any one month; that level triggers a review and is not a limit. Amaranth held as many as 100,000 contracts in a single month.
Margin requirements are the money a trader must keep with the exchanges against possible losses. Amaranth's rose by $944 million on 30 Aug 2006, passed $2.5 billion on ICE and NYMEX on 31 Aug 2006 and $3 billion by 8 Sep 2006.
The loss of more than $2 billion covers the fund's natural gas positions from the last week of August to mid-September 2006, not the whole fund, which managed about $8 billion. The Senate investigation gives no total loss for the fund.
Gas prices are the Henry Hub spot price, in dollars per million British thermal units: $8.15 on average from June to August 2005, and $15.39 on 13 Dec 2005, after Hurricanes Katrina and Rita.
The CFTC's case alleged attempted manipulation; it ended in settlements, Amaranth's in 2009 and Brian Hunter's in 2014.
Every number is computed from the data. How every story is made →
Questions and answers
How much did Amaranth lose?
Its natural gas positions lost more than $2 billion from the last week of August to mid-September 2006; on 29 Aug 2006 alone, nearly $600 million. The Senate investigation gives no total for the whole fund, which managed about $8 billion. A former Amaranth trader told the Senate that the real losses were a little over $4 billion and called a figure of over $6 billion a misconception.
Who took over Amaranth's positions?
On 20 Sep 2006, Amaranth sold its energy positions to its clearing firm, JPMorgan Chase, and to another hedge fund, Citadel.
What happened to Brian Hunter?
In 2007, the CFTC filed a civil action against Amaranth and Brian Hunter, alleging attempted manipulation of natural gas futures prices on 24 Feb 2006 and 26 Apr 2006. Amaranth settled in 2009 and paid a $7.5 million civil penalty. In 2011, the FERC fined Hunter $30 million; a federal appeals court, the D.C. Circuit, overturned the fine on jurisdictional grounds. In 2014, Hunter settled with the CFTC: a $750,000 civil penalty and permanent bans on some kinds of trading.
Data
- 547
i
What: Records
How: The data rows of the tables the video is drawn from, counted at build time.
- records
- 1
- country
- 4
- public datasets
- 2006–2014
- period
Sources: U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, U.S. Energy Information Administration, The Wall Street Journal → Sources & licences