Which car makes fail the MOT most?
Initial MOT fail rate of cars aged 9–12, Great Britain, tests 2021–2025. Same age band for every make.

Tests 2021–2025 · data to December 2025 · updated 2026-10-11
Key facts
- 32 car makes, each with at least 50,000 MOT tests of cars aged 9–12: 40,964,523 tests in Great Britain from 2021 to 2025.
i
What: Scope
How: Normal MOT tests of cars aged 9–12 at the test (test year minus the year of first use), 2021–2025 pooled; makes with fewer tests are not ranked.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- All cars aged 9–12: 32.1 % failed at the first attempt. 13 of 32 makes are above that.
i
What: Average
How: Every test of a car aged 9–12, all makes included: tests that failed at the first attempt ÷ all tests.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- Highest: Renault 44.8 %, Chevrolet 43.6 %, Citroën 40.8 %. Lowest: Porsche 11.8 %, Lexus 17.1 %, Honda 22.5 %.
i
What: Highest and lowest
How: Makes ranked by their initial fail rate, ties decided on the unrounded rates.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- Fail rates climb with age: 12.2 % of cars aged 3 failed at the first attempt, 36.8 % of cars aged 12.
i
What: Age
How: All makes, tests 2021–2025 pooled, by the age of the car at the test.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- The average for cars aged 9–12 fell every year, from 35.4 % in 2021 to 29.4 % in 2025; all 31 makes with enough tests in both years had a lower rate in 2025 than in 2021.
i
What: Year by year
How: The rate in each test year; makes compared where both 2021 and 2025 have at least 1,000 tests.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
Pick a makeExplore
Pick a make: its fail rate against the average, its rank and every test year.
#24 of 32
Toyota
26.4 %
of its cars aged 9–12 failed the first test
1,766,026 tests of cars aged 9–12 counted
- 29.42021
- 27.82022
- 26.82023
- 25.32024
- 23.82025
The explorer and the card need JavaScript. Every make is listed on the ranking page.
Your card
Opens the story with the make selected; social networks show the card as the preview.
https://dotlapse.com/mot-fail-rates/makes/toyota/
Image link: https://dotlapse.com/cards/mot-fail-rates/toyota.png
Free to embed and share with the link back.
How this is computed
Each make's number is its initial MOT fail rate: the share of normal MOT tests in which the car failed when it was first presented, including defects put right at the test station within the hour. Retests are not counted. Tests from 2021 to 2025 in Great Britain are pooled.
Fail rates climb with age, so every make is compared at the same age: cars aged 9 to 12 years at the test. A make is ranked only with at least 50,000 such tests; 32 car makes are ranked. Isuzu is not ranked: almost all of its tested vehicles are pickups. The average line covers every car of that age, all makes included.
Failing an MOT is not the same as unreliability: owners and mileage differ. The test class also includes light vans, so makes that sell vans carry some of them.
Every number is computed from the data. How every story is made →
Questions and answers
Which car makes fail the MOT most?
Renault (44.8 %), Chevrolet (43.6 %) and Citroën (40.8 %): the share of MOT tests of their cars aged 9–12 that failed at the first attempt, 2021–2025. All cars that age: 32.1 %.
Which car makes fail the MOT least?
Porsche (11.8 %), Lexus (17.1 %) and Honda (22.5 %), compared at the same age, 9–12 years.
How is the fail rate calculated?
Tests in which the car failed when it was first presented, including defects put right at the test station within the hour, divided by all normal MOT tests of cars aged 9–12; retests are not counted. Tests from 2021 to 2025 are pooled.
Data
- 32
i
What: Makes ranked
How: Car makes with at least 50,000 MOT tests of cars aged 9–12, 2021–2025.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- makes ranked
- 32.1 %
i
What: All cars aged 9–12
How: Every MOT test of a car that age, all makes included: tests that failed at the first attempt ÷ all tests.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- all cars aged 9–12
- 13
i
What: Above the average
How: Makes whose fail rate is higher than that of all cars aged 9–12.
Source: DVSA MOT test results · data to December 2025.
- above the average
- Renault 44.8 %
Porsche 11.8 % - highest · lowest
Source: DVSA MOT test results → Sources & licences